Do you know about Hart Island? It is a small island, approximately 100-130 acres in size, which lies just off the coast of the Bronx (or actually just off the coast of the larger City Island, which is just off of the coast of Pelham Bay Park). Since the late 1860s, New York City has utilized Hart Island as a potter’s field (and sometime plague burial site). There are (probably) more than a million people buried on the island, most of them nameless and forgotten indigents whose pursuit of New York dreams ultimately led them to this place of oblivion. Comprehensive burial records were destroyed by arson in 1977, so the exact number of bodies on the island is now beyond human ken.
As you might imagine, the history of Hart Island is a cold, sad mirror of the history of New York City (although there are some strange diversions–for example there were underground silos of surface-to-air missiles there during the early Cold War). The public cemetery started out as a small part of the island but, during times of particular crisis or illness, the grave-trenches grew and the other functions receded til ultimately the whole island became a cemetery. At present the island is jointly managed by some unfathomable partnership between the Department of Corrections (whose inmates conduct burials and tend the island) and the Department of Parks which was saddled with administrative control of Hart Island by recent legislation (but which lacks the funds & inclination to make it a proper “park”).
In the island’s recent history, it was utilized as a cemetery for AIDS victims during the first phases of that crisis. In the early eighties, people were afraid and unsure of HIV’s nature and so these AIDS graves are said to be twice as deep as normal.
The inmates who tend Hart Island are solicitous of their solemn charge (a friend of mine who works as a mouthpiece for the Department of Corrections told me that only the most dependable and responsible prisoners are chosen–and they are actually paid for gravedigging and site maintenance). To mark the AIDS cemetery the inmates erected a tiny albeit touchingly earnest peace monument, however they have opined that something more fitting should go there.
That was meant to be the introduction to my idea, however it took me longer to describe New York’s secret “borough of the dead” than I expected (and I never even got to the part about how the island is slowly eroding away leaving a coastline of human bones). Thus, come back next time for part two, where we talk about Hart Island’s future.
6 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 1, 2020 at 7:46 AM
Christine (Sophia)
Excited for the next 2 installments! Stay safe. Socially-distant remote hugs from Buffalo.
May 1, 2020 at 11:59 AM
Wayne
I am so profoundly happy to hear that all is well up there. I miss you and can’t wait to see you again. Maybe I need to visit northern NY–it feels like a whole different country (although so does the grocery store, these days).
May 3, 2020 at 3:53 AM
MiamiMagus
Wouldn’t it be something if this Isle of the Dead did sink? It would be a mini Necropolis that future generations would excavate.
May 5, 2020 at 9:48 PM
Wayne
Well, you may get your wish…the East Coast is a receding coastline, I Kind of got the sense that the move to get the NYC Parks Department to take over was meant to forestall the complete erosion/inundation of the island though.
May 7, 2020 at 12:32 PM
MiamiMagus
Oh I don’t want the Island to sink. I just think it would be something if our descendants in the future ended up excavating it all the way they do in Egypt.
May 11, 2020 at 1:28 PM
Geri Lawhon
I never knew that an island like this existed that close to the Bronx. Knowing how the 2 departments that run it work, there might be more than human remains buried there. Who knows what the future will tell us about this island.