If you have been closely following the affairs of the Andaman Islands, you will know that the North Sentinelese are back in the news of the world. On November 17th, an American Christian missionary named John Allen Chau bribed corrupt fisherman to take him to the forbidden island in the Bay of Bengal. As previously set forth in one of our most popular posts, the island is inhabited by the mysterious North Sentinelese, a stone age hunter-gatherer tribe of unknown language and customs which has spurned all contact with the rest of humankind. The North Sentinelese are bellicose and territorial and they want nothing to do with our networked world of technology, trade, and toil.
The natives, likewise, had no desire to hear John Allen Chau’s proselytizing, and they swiftly dispatched him with arrows and buried his body as quickly as possible (as is their known custom). North Sentinel island is part of India, although the islanders do not seem to recognize (or even know about) their citizenship, and the Indian authorities have been trying to recover Chau’s body. This strikes me as a grave error, since the islanders have demonstrated time and again that they do not desire visitors of any sort. Jesus can worry about his missionary’s final arrangements, thus saving the Indian police from savage battle and saving the islanders from measles, flu, smallpox, or goodness-only-knows what outside disease or influence which they are woefully unprepared for.
Despite ample incontrovertible evidence that the North Sentinelese do not want to integrate into the modern world, there are always arguments about whether the Indian government is operating a “human zoo” (undoubtedly the Sentinelese have some choice descriptions of the interconnected pan-global hive organism that the rest of us are part of, insomuch as they can conceive of it). It strikes me that they have made their choices plain. The worldwide fame/infamy which the North Sentinelese have gained in the last fortnight will quickly fade away, and we can go back to thinking of them as a peculiar alternate sect of humankind—when we think of them at all…
ferrebeekeeper 
2 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 29, 2018 at 9:19 AM
Tutu Dutta
As always, clear and well thought out argument . It’s the people who want to take them out of the island who want to put them in a human zoo. The Sinthelese are a dying race, let them live out their lives, the way they want. I do feel sorry for the young man, though.
January 4, 2019 at 9:55 PM
Wayne
I agree (obviously!) but I also acknowledge that the Sentinelese can’t make an informed choice since their group culture quashes all lines of information which would provide them with knowledge of what is going on out here. I am not really bringing this up as a commentary on hunter gatherer tribes but as a musing about the rest of us. We can’t opt out of the amalgamated world hive in a meaningful way and I suspect we are blinded in all sorts of ways by implicit assumptions made by others (which, like the Sentinelese, we can’t even fathom).